Scarborough RNLI remembers lost crew at their annual memorial service
Scarborough RNLI held its 71st annual memorial service on Sunday 7 December 2025 at St Mary’s Church, continuing a tradition of remembrance that has taken place every year since the tragic loss of the lifeboat ECJR in 1954.
The service was conducted by Rev Sam Tredwell and Rev Pam Jennings, with music provided by the Filey Fishermen’s Choir. Attendees included Cllr Janet Jefferson, members of HM Coastguard, Scarborough Sea Cadets, and many supporters of the RNLI. They were welcomed by Scarborough RNLI Chairperson Colin Woodhead. Readings were given by Scarborough RNLI Deputy 2nd Coxswain Will Watts, Cllr Janet Jefferson, and Rev Pam Jennings. The Roll of Honour was delivered by volunteer crew member Jason Hedges.
The memorial service recalled the events of 8 December 1954, when the Scarborough lifeboat ECJR, a 35-foot self-righting vessel, launched to escort the fishing fleet safely back to harbour as a sudden south-easterly gale struck.
After multiple rescues, the lifeboat attempted to return to Scarborough in worsening seas. On its ninth attempt to enter the harbour, ECJR was overwhelmed by massive waves, capsized, and righted again, leaving five crewmen washed overboard. Despite heroic efforts, Coxswain John Nicholas Sheader, Second Coxswain John Cammish, and Signalman Francis Bayes tragically lost their lives. Their bravery, alongside that of the surviving crew, remains a cornerstone of Scarborough RNLI’s history.
Just days later, the ECJR returned to service with a newly formed crew, including the five survivors of the accident. On 13 December 1954, a funeral service was held at St Mary’s Church, attended by the widows, families, and a large congregation, with the Archbishop of York delivering a heartfelt sermon.
The annual service pays tribute not only to those lost in the ECJR tragedy but also to all 16 crew members who have given their lives in the service of Scarborough lifeboat. Among them is Frank Dalton, who died in an accident three years earlier in tumultuous seas on 9 December 1951.
Roger Buxton, Scarborough RNLI Lifeboat Operations Manager, reflected:
“Every year since this tragedy has been commemorated by a church service remembering their ultimate sacrifice and final act of selflessness. For some, these events may now seem like a distant memory, but to the families of the fallen, they remain ever-present. It is our duty to ensure their courage and sacrifice are never forgotten by the people of Scarborough.”
This year’s service also marked the final RNLI memorial service led by Rev Pam Jennings before her retirement. Scarborough RNLI expressed heartfelt thanks for her years of support and wished her well for the future.
Scarborough RNLI has been saving lives at sea for 224 years. During that time, countless rescues have been carried out, but 16 crew members have made the ultimate sacrifice. Each year, the memorial service ensures their courage and sacrifice are remembered by the community, and that the legacy of Scarborough’s lifeboat crews continues to inspire future generations.
The memorial service remains a vital part of Scarborough’s maritime heritage, bringing together crew, families, and the wider community to honour those who gave their lives so that others might be saved. It is a reminder of the enduring values of courage, duty, and selflessness that define the RNLI.
Key facts about the RNLI
The RNLI is the charity that saves lives at sea. Its volunteers provide a 24-hour search and rescue service around the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland coasts. The RNLI operates 238 lifeboat stations in the UK and Ireland and more than 240 lifeguard units on beaches around the UK and Channel Islands. The RNLI is independent of Coastguard and government and depends on voluntary donations and legacies to maintain its rescue service. Since the RNLI was founded in 1824, its lifeboat crews and lifeguards have saved over 146,700 lives.
Learn more about the RNLI
For more information please visit the RNLI website or Facebook, TikTok and YouTube. News releases, videos and photos are available on the News Centre.
Contacting the RNLI - public enquiries
Members of the public may contact the RNLI on 0300 300 9990 (UK) or 1800 991802 (Ireland) or by email.